An international network of organizations launches campaign to safeguard the Right To Link
May 6, 2015 – A large network of over 50 organizations from 21 countries is coming together to “Save The Link”. Today, the network is launching a multilingual international campaign aimed at pushing back against efforts by powerful media conglomerates to censor links and stifle free expression on the Internet. One of the proposals being advanced could make users personally liable for the content of websites they link to online.
The campaign launches as legislators in the EU are considering a major copyright review, including amendments to the European Union’s Copyright Directive that experts say would fundamentally undermine the right to link. In addition, a recent leak from the European Commission reveals measures that could force online companies to monitor the activities of Internet users in order to block content in other countries.
In tandem with the launch of the campaign, organizers have set up a Thunderclap social media amplification tool demanding that legislators protect the right to link. The message will reach over 1.4 million people.
Considering some of the world's most popular web services are based in the EU, the proposals have implications for Internet users and businesses everywhere. Commenting on the launch of the campaign, OpenMedia Campaigns Coordinator Meghan Sali had this to say:
“The link censorship amendments being considered could restrict the online expression of Internet users around the world. These amendments are out-of-step with our crowdsourced plan for free expression online that over 300,000 people around the world contributed to.”
Sali continued, “The overall proposals from European Parliament Rapporteur Julia Reda are sensible and forward-thinking, and have been acclaimed internationally as a model for global best practice. Sadly, a number of the amendments proposed by other MEPs are frankly irresponsible. If implemented, these extreme amendments would undermine the Right to Link and ruin the Internet as we know it.”
Save the Link Network partners also spoke out on this issue:
Lisette Kalshoven, Kennisland Advisor copyright, heritage and open education: "Europe is in danger of limiting access to culture and knowledge by undermining the right to link.”
Jim Killock, Executive Director of Open Rights Group: “From finding information and sharing our views to joining campaigns and signing up to events - we all use links on a daily basis. Without them, these every day actions would no longer be easily available to us. This would threaten our right to freedom of speech, and deny people around the world the opportunity to engage fully in society and the digital world. Without links, the web cannot function. Threaten links and you threaten the web.”
Dr. Till Kreutzer, Founder of the Initiative against an ancillary copyright for press publishers (IGEL): "Legal restrictions for linking like the ancillary copyright for press publishers jeopardize the free flow of information on the net. Powerful publishers force legislators to restore their monopoly on information, which the Internet only just managed to dissolve."
Caroline De Cock, Copyright 4 Creativity (C4C) coordinator: “Hyperlinking is one of the most fundamental and basic activities of Internet use (by sharing a link on social media, making comments, writing a blog, etc.). The provision of a link pointing to a work or other subject matter protected by copyright should under no circumstances be subject to the authorisation of the rightholder, nor should it induce liability, as the content to which a link points can be changed at all times.”
Ryan Merkley, CEO of Creative Commons: "At its core, the Internet is a network of links — connectivity is at the heart of the Web we love. Breaking that structure by giving some the ability to decide what links should work and what links should not undermines free expression, access to information, and the public commons."
Jeremy Malcolm, Senior Global Policy Analyst at the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF): "There are many threats to speech online, but perhaps none that so fundamentally undermine the fabric of the Internet as those that would constrain our freedom to link."
Carolina Rossini, Public Knowledge Vice President of International Policy: "Sharing information online through hyperlinks is crucial to our freedom of expression. Linking, a core element of how the Web works, enables us to seek, receive and impart information regardless of frontiers, letting us share ideas beyond boundaries. Links are a critical component to the Web, allowing communities to flourish and relationships built on trust and collaboration to emerge. We must join forces across the globe to protect the right to link in Europe and elsewhere, and to ensure the Web doesn't break into pieces."
From proposed new changes to copyright law in Europe, to new takedown demands imposed on web services in several jurisdictions, to a range of Internet censorship activities revealed in the Sony hack, threats to the right to link are emerging around the world:
In Germany, influential press publishers forced legislators to implement an ‘ancillary copyright for press publishers’ that limits how others can link to their news websites. The legislation pushes search engines and news aggregators to acquire licenses for links that include snippets, resulting in lost and inaccessible content.
That same approach was then copied in Spain, where Google News was forced to shut down due to new copyright rules forcing web publishers to pay a fee in order to link out to external content.
In Canada, a provincial court passed a ruling ordering Google to block website search results, not just from its Canadian service, but from its worldwide index.
In the U.S., media conglomerates are trying to exploit obscure trade rules to block access to foreign websites they disapprove of.
Already, over 20,000 people have spoken out at SaveTheLink.org
OpenMedia is an award-winning community-based organization that safeguards the possibilities of the open Internet. We work toward informed and participatory digital policy by engaging hundreds of thousands of people in protecting our online rights.
In October of last year, OpenMedia published a crowdsourced report about copyright in the 21st Century. The report was designed as a response to the secretive and undemocratic processes through which powerful old media conglomerates seek to censor the Internet and restrict the way Internet users share and collaborate online.
Campaigns Coordinator, OpenMedia
Dr. Till Kreutzer
Initiative against ancillary copyright for press publishers (IGEL)
Phone: +49 30 756 387 89